Brand Logo

What Paper Is Best for Prismacolor Pencils? Why Per-Sheet Pricing Is Costing You Money

When you're buying paper for Prismacolor pencils, the price per sheet is the wrong first metric. The surface texture—not the price tag—determines where your pencil budget goes. And pencils make up roughly 80% of the total cost of any colored-pencil program. So paper isn't a minor purchase. It's the critical one.

We bought lightweight drawing paper for three years to go with our Prismacolor pencils. $0.03 a sheet. Half a cent cheaper than the next option. At our volume of about 3,000 sheets a semester, that was $150 in savings. I felt pretty clever about it.

Then the Q1 2023 spending audit changed how I think about paper purchasing. Our accountant flagged a 31% increase in pencil spending over three semesters. No new students. No new program. Just pure waste.

The culprit? The paper was too smooth. Prismacolor Premier pencils have a soft wax/oil-based core. On slick, hot-press paper—like the 50 lb tracing paper we were buying—they smear but don't build up. Students were going over the same area four, five times to get a layer that looked like anything. The coating ate pencils faster than the kids could actually draw.

I'm a procurement manager at a 360-student vocational school's art department. I manage about $65,000 in annual supplies budget, of which roughly $11,000 is art materials. I've been doing this for seven years, negotiated with over 40 vendors, and documented every order in our cost tracking system. Not exactly unfamiliar with this process.

The pencil consumption is the real cost

Here's where most procurement people get it wrong. Paper feels expensive—it comes in big boxes and costs real money. But when a single sheet costs $0.10 and a 24-pack of Prismacolor Premier pencils wholesales for about $19 (as of January 2025, based on our Q4 2024 order), the math stops looking favorable for cheap paper.

We tracked about $12,000 in cumulative Prismacolor pencil spending across our program over two years. On the smooth, cheap paper, our analysis showed we were spending roughly $1,800 more per year in pencil consumption than the prior two-year baseline. That's not even counting the watercolor pencil sets.

About the Prismacolor watercolor pencil set of 12 reviews: we use these in our beginner classes. On regular paper, they wrinkle under wet techniques, so students use more because the paper can't handle the application. The excess pencil consumption is real—and hard to notice, because students assume it's their technique, not the paper.

What paper to actually use with Prismacolor pencils

Here's what we buy now, and why:

Dry media (regular colored pencils)

  • Bristol board, vellum surface: This is the standard. There's enough tooth to grab the wax core without pilling. We use it for final projects.
  • Strathmore 300 Series drawing paper: Reliable middle ground for daily classroom use. More texture than Bristol, but the consumption is acceptable.
  • Avoid: 50 lb lightweight drawing paper. Too smooth, pills easily, and the source of everything wasteful we did.

Prismacolor's own guidance says their soft-core pencils perform best on slightly textured surfaces. On very smooth paper, the color smears rather than builds. It's literally printed on the box—we just didn't pay attention.

Wet media (Prismacolor watercolor pencils)

  • 140 lb cold-press watercolor paper: Non-negotiable. Thinner paper buckles, ruins the artwork, and forces rework.
  • About that Prismacolor watercolor pencil set of 12: It's fine for an introduction, but honestly, 12 colors is limiting once you're doing anything beyond basic exercises. We tried it for one semester—students spent too much time trying to mix intermediate colors. We moved to 24, and class time improved noticeably.

The paper texture can't possibly matter that much

I get it. Paper is paper. How different can it be?

That's what I told myself in spring 2022. I nearly signed an annual contract with a cheaper supplier for their lightweight paper. The contract covered three semesters, about 40 boxes. The savings were roughly $600.

What made me hesitate for two weeks: I ran a pilot test. 50 students, two classes, same curriculum, two paper types, one semester. I asked the teachers to count how many pencil boxes each student went through per semester.

The data: the lightweight paper group averaged 1.3 boxes per student per semester. The Bristol board group used 0.9.

On a 90-student program, that one semester translated to $685 in additional pencil cost.

The $600 in paper savings couldn't be recovered anywhere. We were going to spend nearly $2,000 on pencils that semester regardless.

Honestly, I felt relieved the moment I pulled those pilot results. If I hadn't run it, we'd have locked into that annual contract and spent an extra $1,000 on pencils for the sake of saving $400 on paper—and I probably would have caught it eventually, but the conversation with finance wouldn't have been fun.

My new calculation

Now I run this before every school year starts:

  1. Cost per sheet × student count × expected sheets
  2. + Expected pencil consumption per student × cost per box
  3. + Rework rate (higher with cheaper, smoother paper)
  4. = True cost per student

On the cheap lightweight paper, the result was about $16.80 per student per semester.

On Strathmore 300, it comes out to around $15.20 per student per semester.

The paper looks cheaper. The total doesn't. And I'm not 100% sure that number holds for every program—class sizes vary, curriculums differ, and actual consumption could be closer to $14 or $20 rather than $16. But the ratio usually holds.

The bottom line

If you take one thing from this article, take this: Paper is not a neutral backdrop for Prismacolor pencils. It's an active variable in the math.

The soft core needs texture to grab onto. The less texture you give it, the faster pencils burn through, and the more your overall budget gets eaten alive.

So yes, I'll keep buying mid-range paper. Not the cheapest. Not the most expensive. Just something that survives a semester of pencil work without pilling, without forcing rework, and without needing me to explain why the pencil budget went over again.

That's the better buy. It always will be.

Need help applying this guidance?

Send your printer list, current label SKUs, and the workflow you are trying to improve. Dymo Labels can help translate the article into a practical supply plan.

Ask an Applications Specialist